THE END OF AN ERA
Today I watched an
interview on CNN with Nancy Artwell the recipient of the million dollar global
teaching award. During the discussion she said that she would encourage
creative, imaginative and enthusiastic young people to enter the private sector
of employment and not public school teaching.
Her
rational is that the extreme emphasis on common core standards and the
corollary testing that partners this effort results in teachers becoming technicians
that merely facilitate the implementation of curriculum instead of designing
imaginative learning environments that meet the unique needs of their students
in their classroom.
Teachers are increasingly being denied the
opportunity, in their classroom, to become the professional educator that they
have studied in college and worked thereafter to accomplish. Teachers are being compelled by
school administrators to implement what administrators deem as appropriate
methodologies and strategies to get our students to learn, without mutual
collaborative input with teachers into the design of this process.
In Chicago, this
spring, at the National Science Teachers’ Convention, I found myself
immersed within a sea of new climate-change curriculum ideas, innovative science
research technologies and introduced to volumes of big data from satellites. This is the kind of collaborative experience,
with my peers nation-wide, that helps me to reevaluate my science curriculum in
my school and motivates me to implement new science project initiatives that will
galvanize students to learn to love doing science.
At the convention
I began to wonder if this innovation in the classroom can be sustained. For too long it has been up to the individual
teachers or small groups of teachers to put out the effort and address
innovation in the classroom head-on. For
too long it is has been more of an altruistic effort by individual teachers
within schools to change curriculum to meet the needs of students and prepare
them for the challenges they face in the 21st century.
Today there is marginal investment by school
districts to fund the needed curriculum initiatives that can deliver increased academic
achievement in the classroom for all students.
Districts maligned with meeting state mandates, implementing new testing
strategies and squeezing budgets along with reducing faculty and staff do not
address critical aspects of learning.
The assault upon the profession of teaching continues as more and more
top-down education programs relegate teachers to the position of merely
proctors of a process.
Educators, like
myself, holding time-honored ideals of commitment and perseverance in education
continue to work to deliver inspired and relevant learning opportunities for
our students in a 21st century classroom. This effort by teachers has become a heavy
lift and it will be difficult to sustain without more district support. If more support for cutting-edge curriculum
initiatives is not put forth by school districts for teacher-centered
ideas, then the learning process in the classroom will cave into the technical
application of prescribed standards-based curriculum along with their corollary
testing.
It is
disappointing to me that after 20 years of avocation for innovation and
cutting-edge curriculum initiatives in the science classroom and for decades attending
many of the largest gatherings of science educators in the world, that I now feel
a sense of watching an era in education coming to a close. Project-based and real-world applications
being sidelined in favor of prescribed uniform pedagogy along with
standards-based curriculum and district-wide testing and evaluation. The new
generation of technician teachers will suite district purposes more
appropriately from here on and with perceived greater district-based efficiency. I do not know where the learning in the
classroom goes to in all of this, but I suspect that it too will becoming a relic.
1 comment:
Greg,
You are, as always, right on point. I was reading an article about Finland doing what I have advocated for over 20 years - implementing thematic teaching. Perhaps it's time to get out our passports and take a field trip.
Carol
Post a Comment